Adding a follow up/update:
Thursday evening we were playing cribbage when talk turned towards her mother, dying of a terminal illness, and a request that I pray for those affected. I expressed my condolences, but declined to do any praying. Talk then turned to whether I believe "just a little", and when I still refused, it was very sad that I did not. Then started the extremely insulting, IMO, talk of "you look but do not see, listen but do not hear or understand" BS. Not being interested in changing her beliefs or being equally insulting in return, I merely inquired "Do you think that I could talk you out of your beliefs?" to which she seemed to get the point. After one final "I know you believe deep down", we said our good nights. We haven't talked since and honestly, I don't know that I care to anymore.